Ahmadinejad, Part I

Quote of the day:

"In Iran, we don't have homosexuals like in your country. We don't have this phenomenon. I don't know who told you that we have them" --President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad when asked about the human rights abuses levied against homosexuals in Iran


Yesterday, I attended the lecture by President Ahmadinejad at Columbia University. You probably have seen or read clips from it by now because it was all over the domestic and international news yesterday and this morning. Campus was in controlled chaos all day long. There were camera crews set up outside the main gates, and throngs of protesters were there as well. Only those with Columbia ID were allowed in the gates, but once you stepped foot on the main campus, the scene wasn't much different. Rallies and protests took place throughout the day: some in support of free speech, some chastising the university for extending the invitation in the first place, some reviewing the litany of grievances against Ahmadinejad, and some managing to do all three. Although the speech wasn't scheduled until 1:30, there were students with tickets lined up as early as 10am to get in. I didn't bother to arrive until 1:00. Once I saw the mob scene outside of the auditorium, I became worried that I wasn't going to get in, but once I did get in, I saw that there was still plenty of room.

The major disappoint for the day came at the very beginning with the opening remarks of University President Lee Bollinger. His version of opening the discussion with a challenge to Ahmadinejad was simply a 25-minute tirade in which he caved to the pressure of special interest and politicians. The following insults that Bollinger lobbed at Ahmadinejad do a good job at characterizing the overall tone of his remarks:

“You exhibit all of the signs of a petty and cruel dictator”

“You are either brazenly provocative or astonishingly uneducated”

“I doubt that you’ll have the intellectual courage to answer these questions”


The major disappoint of his remarks were not just the words themselves, but rather the embarrassingly un-academic nature of them, and Ahmadinejad did a very good job at calling him on it. Beyond his assertion that Bollinger’s remarks were no way to treat an invited guest, Ahmadinejd remarked that a man who purports to champion free speech cannot reasonably expect to have an open and free dialogue when he just spent nearly a half an hour spewing bias and closemindedness. Anything that Ahmadinejad said from that point on would be colored by Bollinger’s obviously biased comments.

I am very disappointed in President Bollinger. I think it’s shameful that the head of a major university would so obviously bend to the pressures of outside actors. Academia is about the search for truth. He simply can’t allow special interest, politicians, and other outsiders to divert him from this goal.

Ahmadinejad’s prepared remarks opened with a quote from the Koran, and he then went on to espouse the virtue of science and research and speak on its edifying effects on mankind for 15 minutes. It was clearly a set up for his argument for further research on the Holocaust, but the audience was not impressed. 10 minutes into it people were clearly losing interest. I saw people chatting, checking their Blackberries, and the guy next to me even started to read a newspaper.

Once we got past that point, however, things started to get more interesting.

Chocolate Slaves

Much like the African diamond trade that has received a great deal of attention in recent years, there is yet another natural resource trade in parts of Africa that is chiefly consumed in the West, but is having devastating effects on the lives of normal Africans: chocolate cultivation in parts of West Africa.

By some estimates, 50% of the world's cocoa beans come from Ghana and Côte d'Ivoire. This cocoa is shipped abroad to a central location, mixed together with cocoa beans from around the world and then sold and turned into chocolate. This is common knowledge and should not come as a surprise to anyone. However, what is not commonly known, but is very well documented by the cocoa industry is that given the very low world prices for cocoa, many plantations in Ghana and Côte d'Ivoire find it necessary to use child slave labor to plant and harvest their crops. Which is often the case with forced child labor, the children are either sold to the plantation owners by poor families or simply kidnapped. These children work very long hours and receive little or no education or training outside of cocoa cultivation. Given the fact that cocoa beans are aggregated and then sent out for processing, there is no way to know whether the conventional chocolate bar you're eating came at least in part from beans harvested by workers in Latin America or child slavery in West Africa.

There have been some notable efforts on the part of the US Government to fight this problem, but progress has been painfully slow and, of course, the cocoa industry has been dragging its feet. US Senator Tom Harkin (D-IA) and US Rep Eliot Engel (D-NY) sponsored the Harkin-Engel Protocol of 2001, which calls for voluntary industry-side standards with respect to child labor by July 2005, was signed by both the Chocolate Manufacturers Association (CMA) and the World Cocoa Foundation (WCF), but over two years after the deadline, the standards still have yet to be implemented. Furthermore, Tulane University's Payson Center for International Development was tapped by US Secretary of Labor Elaine Choa to spearhead a project to oversee efforts to eliminate the worst forms of child labor in the West African cocoa industry.

Fortunately, despite widespread knowledge of this issue among your ordinary chocolate consumers, some progress is being made. However, there is still a lot more that needs to be done. I think that the most important and practical thing that we all can do would be to raise awareness of the issue. Most people just don't know. I personally only found out recently when I was having lunch with a group of high school students over the summer as part of my internship and one of the students brought it up. The more people that know about this, the more it becomes a public relations issue for the chocolate industry and the more likely they are to take steps to fix the problem.

Another practical step that we all can take is to only buy Fair Trade chocolate. It's the only way that you can be reasonably sure that the chocolate was harvested on farms and plantations that do not utilize slave labor. It's a little more expensive and often not as good, but it gets the job done and it gives you that wonderful feeling of moral superiority over all those consuming traditionally manufactured chocolates.

For more information:
Tulane University Public Health
Harkin-Engel Protocol
World Cocoa Foundation
Chocolate Manufacturers Association

The Axis of Evil Right in Our Own Backyard

Several heads of state will be in town for the UN General Assembly meeting this week and next. As is the custom every year, my university invites world leaders to come speak on campus while they're passing through New York. This year, among others, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the current president of Iran, has confirmed that he will speak and remain for a Q&A session. And guess who just scored a ticket?!

That's right, I'll be there soaking in all of the magic. This guy's a f-ing lunatic. It's going to be awesome!

I wonder whether he'll report on the event in his blog.